KeiSei Magazine
  • Fashion
    • Style
    • Ethical Talks
    • Editorials
  • Beauty
    • Skincare
    • Beauty Edit
  • Lifestyle
    • Wellbeing
    • Culture
    • Home
    • Guides
  • Inspiration
    • In Conversation With
    • The Climate Optimist
    • Editors Journal
    • Book Club
  • Shop
    • Fashion
      • Tops
      • Bottoms
      • Knitwear
      • Dresses & Jumpsuits
      • Outwear
      • Activewear
      • Jeans
    • Accessories
      • Bags
      • Hats & Bonnets
      • Scarves
      • Shoes
    • Beauty
      • Skincare
      • Hair
      • Body
      • Make-up
KeiSei Magazine
  • Fashion
    • Style
    • Ethical Talks
    • Editorials
  • Beauty
    • Skincare
    • Beauty Edit
  • Lifestyle
    • Wellbeing
    • Culture
    • Home
    • Guides
  • Inspiration
    • In Conversation With
    • The Climate Optimist
    • Editors Journal
    • Book Club
  • Shop
    • Fashion
      • Tops
      • Bottoms
      • Knitwear
      • Dresses & Jumpsuits
      • Outwear
      • Activewear
      • Jeans
    • Accessories
      • Bags
      • Hats & Bonnets
      • Scarves
      • Shoes
    • Beauty
      • Skincare
      • Hair
      • Body
      • Make-up
0

Wishlist

Please, add your first item to the wishlist

  • ETHICAL TALKS

Leather: Material or Materialism?

  • 7 minute read
© Claudia de la Mata

By Beatrice Tridimas

Earlier this month, California became the first state to ban the selling and manufacturing of fur. California is not the first, however, with the likes of Serbia, Luxembourg and Norway already on the way to a fur-free future. Motivated by animal rights activism, California’s bill, somehow, excludes the ban of leather. It seems leather is subject to a much more complex debate.

Unlike fur, leather is no longer the symbol of a luxury item. Now a seasonal staple in high demand, more and more brands are seeking to sell leather products. There is a distinct attempt to develop a sustainable practice of using real leather. This is fuelled by a concern over plastic-based leather alternatives and the conviction that leather is a by-product of the meat industry that would otherwise go to waste.

Legitimising the use of real animal skins, however, remains controversial. Considering that leather and fur share many of the negatives of animal farming, can we really continue to justify the use of real leather in the face of fur’s unpopularity?

 

A Case Against Leather

 

The use of animal hides is inevitable whilst the meat and dairy industry exist, most leather being bought as a ‘by-product’. However, labelling leather a mere ‘by-product’ exonerates its contribution to the perpetuation of animal farming and its environmental consequences.

Leather is the most economically valuable part of the animal. In 2015, the international trade value of raw animal hides was 6.92 billion dollars. It’s incorrect to think that leather is a mere ‘by-product’ when it generates so much income. Buying leather pours money into the farming industry, becoming a primary motivation for animal slaughtering and bad farming practices.

Even though there will always be a market for leather whilst we continue to eat meat and dairy, we ought not underplay the economic contribution leather makes to the farming industry. Reducing the amount of leather we buy will have some impact on the success of the farming industry and its production rates.

Regardless of being a by-product or primary product, leather production inevitably shares in the environmental harms of animal farming. Thus, whilst we continue to use leather, we continue to have a negative effect on the environment.

A study carried out by the UN in 2013 revealed that animal agriculture is the second largest contributor to Greenhouse Gases. A statistic, probably unsurprising, considering that cows produce 150 billion gallons of methane a day. As well as hazardous flatulence, raising animals requires a lot of land, water and fossil fuels. In a 2009 report, Greenpeace found that cattle rearing is the world’s largest driver of deforestation.

PETA declares that the leather industry has ‘the greatest impact on eutrophication’, from the combination of its animal wastes and tanning wastes. Tanning processes use significant amounts of energy and heavy chemicals, whilst research suggests that exposure to chemicals is related to an increased risk of cancer.

Inextricably bound with the meat and dairy industry, leather production shares in the environmental impacts of animal farming, contributing further damage from tanning processes.

Jolie Laide belt bag
Jolie Laide belt bag
Zoa bio fabricated leather
Zoa bio fabricated leather
 

A saving grace for leather?

 

Speaking with Jacqueline Flaggiello, an advocate of sustainable leather and founder of Jolie Laide, it is clear that the leather industry doesn’t have to be this way. ‘The system only exists,’ she says, ‘because there is a demand.’ As consumers, we seek to buy cheap leather, so cheap leather is produced. It is the cheapest leather that has the worst effect on the environment. Manufacturers can force five pieces of leather out of one skin, by splitting it finely and coating each sheet in chemicals. Lower-quality leather won’t last as long and is more likely to end up in landfill.

Flaggiello combines style, quality and sustainability in her conscious production of leather accessories. She uses only leather that is a by-product, and dyes it using vegetable tanning. Chemical dying took over the leather industry when companies wanted to produce faster and cheaper, ‘mass consumerism’ to blame.

Leather was never made for fast fashion. It’s a good quality material, durable, ‘used when they were making products that […] were not disposable.’ If we refine what we consider leather to be, to that of the highest-grade, eventually, the cheapest, lowest-grade leather will find no market. The best-quality leather lasts us a lifetime and we don’t need to keep producing cheaply and quickly. Producing the highest-grade leather, grade A, ‘the animals are treated the best, and the leather is the best quality.’

There will always be a market for leather whilst the meat and dairy industry continue to thrive. ‘If you want people to stop using leather,’ Flaggiello points out, ‘then we need to stop eating that much meat. They are directly correlated.’ Whilst this is perhaps an ultimate aim of some sort, for the time being, we can use the excess of animal hides wisely and tailor the market so that less and less come into production.

 

Perilous Pleather

Despite the perpetuation of the leather industry, there are a number of faux leathers on the market. So, what are they and how do they fare in the eyes of sustainability?

Many faux leathers are plastic based. Unlike straws, take-away cups and packaging, our pleather pieces aren’t single use plastics (I’d hope anyway). Yet, as consumerism accelerates and our wardrobe turnover quickens, much of our clothing ends up in landfill. For the same reason that paper straws replace plastic ones in most establishments, and Gatwick airport let customers borrow cups this summer instead of providing reusable ones, we ought to resist buying and wearing plastics, no matter how many uses we get from them.

Plastic leathers are most commonly made from PU or vinyl (PVC). Like all plastics, PU and PVC aren’t biodegradable and are produced using heavy chemicals and lots of fossil fuels. Whilst PU is considered slightly better than PVC, branded the ‘the single most environmentally damaging type of plastic’ by Greenpeace, neither plastic offers a hugely sustainable alternative to real leather.
Pinatex trainers for Hugo Boss
Pinatex trainers for Hugo Boss
Vegan trainers from Veja
Vegan trainers from Veja
 

If you like piña coladas…

 

There are, however, many more sustainable alternatives in development. Piñatex, a fusion material, based on a fibre made from pineapple leaves, is gaining popularity due to its use by high profile brands, such as Hugo Boss.

80% of Piñatex is pineapple leaf fibre, the other 20% is PLA (polylactic acid fibres). This means that Piñatex is a bioplastic. Whilst the substrate, the PLA-Pineapple base of the material is biodegradable, its coating isn’t, thus it isn’t labelled as a biodegradable alternative. However, Piñatex manufacturers ensure that the petroleum-based coating they use is certified by environmental and textile agencies and is committed to finding a biodegradable finish that will make Piñatex 100% environmentally friendly in the future.

Whilst the end result might not be perfect, its manufacturing process is pretty clean, as the key-component is a genuine by-product of pineapple farming. Furthermore, any waste from the leaf is turned into a biofuel and returned to farming communities.

Whilst Piñatex are doing their best to develop a 100% biodegradable, sustainable leather, it’s important to note that, according to this 2015 study carried out by the GPA, bio-plastics aren’t completely biodegradable in water and thus continue to contribute to sea-pollution.

Plastic-based leather alternatives might seem to simply substitute one set of environmental consequences for another, although we cannot ignore the efforts made to make the entire process more sustainable.

Laptop case from Been London
Laptop case from Been London

Fear not faux

 

Not every faux leather contains plastic. There are some really exciting alternatives in development, including Modern Meadow’s Zoa, a leather-like material created in a lab from collagen protein. Otherwise brands like Veja or Been London are using recycled materials, like plastic bottles, corn waste and recycled leather to create new clothing.

 

Not so conscious consumerism

 

What underlies the problems of both real leather and sustainable leather is not just what we are buying, but how we buy. Flaggiello intends with her products to invoke a more conscious consumerism, encouraging her buyers to give up fast-fashion. She designs products that we buy for life, ‘I really try to stay away from trends in design […] try to make it so that any age group can wear it, any season: seasonless, ageless, timeless.’

Obsessive consumerism defines 21st century culture. The more that the consumer wants, the more the market can provide, Flaggiello reminds us, ‘people won’t say no to making money, we’re not in that world.’

It’s up to you, up to the consumer to change their attitude towards buying. ‘I think we should make an effort in truly becoming educated as consumers,’ Jacqueline says, ‘And buying less, much, much less, and buying higher quality, and […] taking our time to research and figure out how things are made.’
‘It’s each individual persons’ job […] it’s your physical responsibility on this earth, to be aware of what you consume […] and how you contribute to society.’

Slowly, as we change our buying habits, the markets will transform, and those industries that pose a threat to the environment, to the future of our planet, those will, eventually, shut down.

What do we want from a ‘sustainable’ leather?

 

Sustainability is not just about finding a material that is biodegradable, or durable, or organic. It’s the whole process, it’s where the material is from, it’s how the product is made, it’s how you treat the product. Sustainability is both buying products that last you a lifetime and buying products that are ethically produced and will biodegrade when you’re done.

Creating a truly sustainable future is a long and slow process and involves taking down entire industries. But taking the smallest action can begin to make a change.

Knowing where your products are coming from is the best way to make the right choices for you, and the environment. Keep supporting brands that are sourcing their materials in the best way, whether those be sustainable faux leathers, or high-grade real leather. Change your attitude to buying. Buy once and buy for life.

Slowly, we can eliminate those materials that are the worst, and pave our way to a more sustainable future.

Beatrice Tridimas

Beatrice Tridimas

Beatrice is an ethicist and book-lover, pursuing her passion for writing at KeiSei whilst studying for a masters degree at UCL. She graduated from the University of Edinburgh earlier this year.

Beatrice Tridimas

Previous Article
  • ETHICAL TALKS

The Future Of Fashion Shows

View Post
Next Article
A rental revolution, Hurr Collecctive
  • ETHICAL TALKS

Is Renting The Future Of Fashion?

View Post

KeiSei Weekly:

Sign-Up For A Weekly Dose Of Sustainable Lifestyle Inspiration

You May Also Like
The Ultimate Guide To Creating A Sustainable Home
View Post
  • Guides
  • Home

The Ultimate Guide To Creating A Sustainable Home

  • Cecilia Toro
  • April 6, 2022
A modern, minimalistic living room with muted, natural tones and modern furniture. Photographed by Nicole Franzen.
View Post
  • Home

We Need To Talk About Fast Homeware

  • Ellen Prizeman
  • April 6, 2022
Alicja Kwade, "Big Be-Hide", 2017. photo by Maija Toivanen:Helsinki Biennial⁣⁣
View Post
  • Culture

What Does Sustainability Mean For The Art World?

  • Eleonora Cerasoli
  • April 6, 2022
View Post
  • Home

How To Implement The Danish Principles Of Hygge

  • Raegan Rubin
  • April 6, 2022
living space
View Post
  • Home

Get Cosy For Autumn With These Sustainable Interior Trends

  • Sophie Weissensteiner
  • April 6, 2022
Intentional Shopping: How To Shop Mindfully On A High Street Budget
View Post
  • ETHICAL TALKS

Intentional Shopping: How To Shop Mindfully On A High Street Budget

  • Charlotte Hope-Shannon
  • January 11, 2022
bathroom
View Post
  • Home

How To Give Your Bathroom A Sustainable Makeover

  • Lily Corcoran
  • April 6, 2022
5 Tips for Dealing with Climate News
View Post
  • The Climate Optimist

Awareness Hurts & That’s OK, 5 Tips for Dealing with Climate News

  • Anne Therese Gennari
  • December 22, 2021

KeiSei Weekly

Sign-Up for more Inspiration on Sustainable Living and Style Direct to Your Inbox

⁠ 57 5
Want to be in on a secret? ⁠ 42 2
Skincare or hair care? ⁠ 36 2
Have you been invited to a Halloween party and need some inspiration? ⁠ 25 1
Are you making the most of the cocooning season? ⁠ 37 2
Have you tried rental fashion yet?⁠ 41 3
KeiSei Magazine
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Terms of service
  • Privacy policy
© 2020 KeiSei Magazine Ltd.

Input your search keywords and press Enter.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Cookie settingsACCEPT
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT