KeiSei Magazine
  • Fashion
    • Style
    • Ethical Talks
    • Editorials
  • Beauty
    • Skincare
    • Beauty Edit
  • Lifestyle
    • Wellbeing
    • Culture
    • Home
    • Guides
  • Inspiration
    • In Conversation With
    • The Climate Optimist
    • Editors Journal
    • Book Club
  • Shop
    • Fashion
      • Tops
      • Bottoms
      • Knitwear
      • Dresses & Jumpsuits
      • Outwear
      • Activewear
      • Jeans
    • Accessories
      • Bags
      • Hats & Bonnets
      • Scarves
      • Shoes
    • Beauty
      • Skincare
      • Hair
      • Body
      • Make-up
KeiSei Magazine
  • Fashion
    • Style
    • Ethical Talks
    • Editorials
  • Beauty
    • Skincare
    • Beauty Edit
  • Lifestyle
    • Wellbeing
    • Culture
    • Home
    • Guides
  • Inspiration
    • In Conversation With
    • The Climate Optimist
    • Editors Journal
    • Book Club
  • Shop
    • Fashion
      • Tops
      • Bottoms
      • Knitwear
      • Dresses & Jumpsuits
      • Outwear
      • Activewear
      • Jeans
    • Accessories
      • Bags
      • Hats & Bonnets
      • Scarves
      • Shoes
    • Beauty
      • Skincare
      • Hair
      • Body
      • Make-up
0

Wishlist

Please, add your first item to the wishlist

  • Culture

Has Cancel Culture Gone Too Far?

  • 8 minute read
Cancel Culture. A woman has her mouth covered.
Photo by cottonbro

By Eleonora Cerasoli

Imagine the world reflected by a distorting mirror, always presenting a new and very much different version of itself to those who look. The complexity of this world can only be perceived by constantly looking at things from a different perspective. The society we live in, its history, its ideas, its literature and fashion are the result of this complexity.

What happens if the complexity of the world we live in, and so ours as human beings is jeopardized by a new justice system where social media are the new courtroom and everyone gets to exercise judicial power from behind their screen? 

What are the dangers of Cancel culture? Is it a tool to achieve social justice or a menace to free speech? Can Cancel Culture help to increase awareness on controversial and pressing issues or is it simply casting stones without leaving space to dialogue and progress?

Let’s celebrate National Conversation week by raising discussion about this complex subject. 

What is Cancel Culture? 

It consists in cancelling, denouncing, boycotting, excluding from debate, from public or professional space, any person deemed unapproachable by their opinions, their behaviour, or simply considered to be resistant to the morals of the new times. It exhorts people to stay “woke”, a term meaning a state of constant awareness to denounce social and racial crimes, which attracted criticism for its aggressive nature.  

Cancel culture: when social media meets social justice

We feel very passionate about defending the right to speak of those who share our same ideas and point of views, but we forget to extend the rights to those who aren’t in agreement with us, especially if we feel that their ideas are menacing our society. Certainly, this sentiment grew stronger in the past years, proving that our society demands more equality and inclusivity, incessantly calling out discrimination, prejudices, marginalisation and racism. 

The general feeling is that we had enough; we let too many injustices pass by without consequences in the past, so now something has to be done. Welcome to social media, a powerful tool to make things right, to shut down the hateful voices and restore equality. If the freedom of speech gets a bit shadowed on the way, it’s a price we’re willing to pay for a better world…Right?

Is it really that simple? Is the line between right and wrong so clear and universal? What if we’re choosing the shortcut to change, jeopardizing some fundamental rights that could create a dangerous precedent for our future society? I think we can achieve change without limiting freedom of speech, without staining the amazing achievements past generations obtained with long and painful fights!
MeToo movement. Three women are standing holding signs advocating against sexual harassment
Photo by cottonbro

Is there any space left for forgiveness? 

If we take the MeToo movement, for example, it is hard not to praise cancel culture for its effectiveness, as the court of public opinion seemed to be the only place left for justice for these women, failed by their workplace’s protection system and the judicial system. 

The debate lays in the irreversibility of the sentence: once one is cancelled, they stay cancelled. While this could arguably be a great solution to keep sex offenders out of the entertainment industry, it’s imperative to think about the consequences of these cancellations on minor or more complex cases. 

If we decide to bypass the legal system because ineffectual, can we substitute it with one built by a culture that does not consider forgiveness, reviews and reconsideration? 

Woke: the politically correct rises to an ideology 

The idea of guilt by accusation (guilt is assumed of those who are accused) is a dangerous thing that can seem justifiable at times, but we should remember our history and times where it was used to justify forms of oppression. 

What happens when cancellations become an easy manifest for big companies to cover up real issues?Can we overlook cases where the punishment doesn’t fit the offense?
 

Like the case of a police detective, Florissa Fuentes fired over a repost of a picture of her niece at BLM protest, which included a sign “implying that people should shoot back at the police”. Neither deleting the post nor apologizing was deemed enough to reverse the “sentence”. 

Others like Emmanuel Cafferty were innocents and didn’t get a change to defend themselves. Cafferty, a truck driver, was tricked into making an “Okay” symbol by a driver he cut off at a traffic light. The video went viral, insinuating that the okay sign was a white-suprematist gesture and he lost his job as a result. 

People lose their jobs for re-tweeting the wrong opinion, people are forced to resign for posts or comments that they made years before, and we seem to be heading dangerously towards a culture that rejects the notion of nuanced debate. 

“This mechanism is not a long-overdue settling of scores by underrepresented voices. It is a reflexive jerk of the knee by the powerful, a demonstration of institutions’ unwillingness to tolerate any controversy, whether those complaining are liberal or conservative.” – Helen Lewis

With social media certainly comes great power, one that unfortunately can be abused, but can progress come from this apparent toxic movement?

The other face of the medal: is call-out culture good for society? 

Call-out culture refers to interpersonal confrontation occurring between individuals generally on social media. The premise seems pretty clear: you do something wrong, someone points it out for it not to happen again. But opinions on the matter are yet again very polarized. Former President Obama said: 

“I do get a sense sometimes now among certain young people, and this is accelerated by social media, that the way of me making change is to be as judgmental as possible about other people and that’s enough.”

Diversity. The hands of three people of different color are holding to each other
Photo by cottonbro

On the other side, the debate on almost everything, from politics to literature to gender relations has never been more inclusive, featuring a range of voices so wide and diversified. This diversity could be a threat to some, used to express their point of views without interruption or disagreement. 

Some of these defenders of free speech seem to have confused dialogues with monologues!

Freedom of speech not freedom of consequences 

When acknowledging instead of cancelling the damages that certain opinions have on our society, it reinforces freedom of speech as you come to the understanding that some problems need to be taken into consideration, and for which solutions need to be found. That’s how freedom of expression resists! 

For instance, J.K. Rowling, after some controversial tweets that labelled her as transphobic, posted a long essay on her blog explaining her position. She does a good job in camouflaging her transphobia and coming across as quite reasonable. The essay is a result of misinformation, made of half-truths from unspecified sources, brilliantly packaged by a great author, that could dangerously sway the minds of people who know little about the trans community, against it. 

The damage that she has done with this essay to the trans community would seem a valuable reason to cancel her, but I believe that greater good has been done by those who very clearly and peacefully broke down Rowling’s essay and unveiled all the lies. She doesn’t give any citation or source, she falsifies media reports inflating and sensationalising statistics. 

She was portrayed as a “victim” of cancel culture, which makes it necessary to clarify: you can’t treat people with less respect just because you don’t agree with them and not face any consequences. 
If someone uses their freedom of speech to lie and generate fear, is it wrong to call them out for it?

Is cancel culture damaging creativity?

Cancel Culture is eliminating everything in human history that is essentially unacceptable going as further as removing the Odyssey from the school program because Homer was a racist. With the slogan #DisruptTexts people demand the prohibition of every masterpiece non-conform on gender and race.

This anti-intellectual movement is becoming progressively more popular amongst educators and the editorial industry, raising the question as to whether this battle of the politically correct isn’t bringing censorship back on the table. 

Do we need to protect our children from cultural works of the past instead of educating them to fight the battle in the present? 

Let’s accept history to reactivate diversity!

Opinions vs. facts: the right to talk about everything 

Nobel prize for Literature Kazuo Ishiguro condemns cancel culture for creating a climate of fear, which is inhibiting the creative liberty of younger writers, who feel the pressure to censor themselves. The author stated there ought to be “decency towards people outside of one’s own immediate experience” and that “a more open discussion about cancel culture and freedom of speech” is needed.

Censorship. A person holding their other hand as to refrein themselves from action.
Photo by Anete Lusina

Alexandra Duncan decided not to publish her book Ember Days because it told the story of an Afro-American Gullah, and as a white female she realizes not to be the right person to tell this story. The literary agent Natasha Fairweather observes:

“The mood is becoming so militant that you are no longer allowed to write from the perspective of anyone other than yourself” 

Men have written about women, white people about black people. We have the right to talk and write about everything, but we have the duty to research and inform ourselves! The problem doesn’t lie in white men having a voice, but in that voice being the only one we can hear. 

Does call-out culture make brands more authentic?

With the growth of social media allowing everyone to have a voice, people are more vocal about companies’ mistakes and are more critical than ever towards brands. According to the 2018 Edelman Earned Brand study, nearly two-thirds (64%) of consumers around the world will buy or boycott a brand solely because of its position on a social or political issue. 

At the same time, the cultural debate penetrated the fashion industry and not taking sides can be the bigger risk.

Calling out brands for their mistakes can certainly be an opportunity to create authentic identities but we have to leave them space to improve! It is important to notice how this constant consumers’ demand for brands to take a stand planted more doubt around the genuineness of brands. 

The 2019 Edelman Trust Barometer Special Report: In Brands We Trust? showed that 56% of consumers said that too many brands are using societal issues as a marketing ploy. Brands are reacting to the ever more pressing need to reflect societal values, but we have to direct our vigilance to the authenticity of their actions. 
Life is not a battle between good and evil people

Good and evil are not as binary as in the Harry Potter saga. Works are set in a specific place and time, people on the contrary can evolve, make mistakes, choose to take accountability for their actions or not and live and react through the consequences. 

Choosing conversation over cancellation 

I want to conclude with 3 things we should all have in mind when navigating online: 

  • When we read or hear about something controversial we might form an instant opinion, but it is important to take time to conduct appropriate research to acquire the perspective we need to understand a complex topic. 
  • It is necessary to ask ourselves why we want to be part of the conversation. Social media can be an amazing platform to discuss issues, but we have to do it for the right reasons. Ask yourself why are you passionate about it? Why is it important that your voice is heard? Can you bring a valuable contribution to the table?
  • Always remember: “When you debate a person about something that affects them more than it affects you, remember that it will take a much greater emotional tool on them than on you. For you it may feel like an academic exercise. For them, it feels like revealing their pain only to have you dismiss their experience and sometimes their humanity. The fact that you might remain more calm under these circumstances is a consequence of your privilege, not increased objectivity on your part. Stay humble.” Sarah Maddux.

I believe conversation is necessary to keep seeing progress in our society. What do you think? Do you know any case of cancellation that you deemed unfair? Let us know your opinion about this complex topic in the comments!

Eleonora Cerasoli

Eleonora Cerasoli

Eleonora is an Italian art historian and enthusiast based in London. Inspired years ago to make a change and live a more sustainable life, she now wants to empower readers through her writing. "One book, one pen, one child, and one teacher can change the world."

Shop our seasonal favourites here

 
  • double face wool capebuy in arket

    Double-Face Wool Cape

    Arket
    £150.00
    Add to wishlist
  • TRETORN Women's Rain Hatbuy in arket

    TRETORN Women’s Rain Hat

    Arket
    £45.00
    Add to wishlist
  • Ingela Leather Black boots Sale! buy in flattered

    Ingela Leather Black

    Flattered
    £279.00 £209.00
    Add to wishlist
  • GANNI half-zip cable-knit jumper Sale! BUY IN FARFETCH

    Half-zip cable-knit jumper

    Ganni
    £600.00 £480.00
    Add to wishlist
  • ruffled checked cotton mini dress and hair tie set Sale! buy in net-a-porter

    Josepha ruffled checked cotton mini dress and hair tie set

    MaisonCléo
    £304.00 £212.80
    Add to wishlist
  • &DAUGHTER + NET SUSTAIN Constance merino wool cardiganBuy in net-a-porter

    Constance merino wool cardigan

    &Daughter
    £285.00
    Add to wishlist
  • &DAUGHTER Kesh cable-knit wool sweaterBuy in Net-a-porter

    Kesh cable-knit wool sweater

    &Daughter
    £385.00
    Add to wishlist
  • camel handbag mediumPre-order in MASHU

    Aphrodite Camel

    MASHU
    £300.00
    Add to wishlist
Eleonora Cerasoli

Previous Article
Art and Culture: must see exhibitions in 2021
  • Culture

Art & Culture: Must See Exhibitions In 2021

View Post
Next Article
Alicja Kwade, "Big Be-Hide", 2017. photo by Maija Toivanen:Helsinki Biennial⁣⁣
  • Culture

What Does Sustainability Mean For The Art World?

View Post

KeiSei Weekly:

Sign-Up For A Weekly Dose Of Sustainable Lifestyle Inspiration

You May Also Like
The Ultimate Guide To Creating A Sustainable Home
View Post
  • Guides
  • Home

The Ultimate Guide To Creating A Sustainable Home

  • Cecilia Toro
  • April 6, 2022
A modern, minimalistic living room with muted, natural tones and modern furniture. Photographed by Nicole Franzen.
View Post
  • Home

We Need To Talk About Fast Homeware

  • Ellen Prizeman
  • April 6, 2022
Alicja Kwade, "Big Be-Hide", 2017. photo by Maija Toivanen:Helsinki Biennial⁣⁣
View Post
  • Culture

What Does Sustainability Mean For The Art World?

  • Eleonora Cerasoli
  • April 6, 2022
View Post
  • Home

How To Implement The Danish Principles Of Hygge

  • Raegan Rubin
  • April 6, 2022
living space
View Post
  • Home

Get Cosy For Autumn With These Sustainable Interior Trends

  • Sophie Weissensteiner
  • April 6, 2022
Intentional Shopping: How To Shop Mindfully On A High Street Budget
View Post
  • ETHICAL TALKS

Intentional Shopping: How To Shop Mindfully On A High Street Budget

  • Charlotte Hope-Shannon
  • January 11, 2022
bathroom
View Post
  • Home

How To Give Your Bathroom A Sustainable Makeover

  • Lily Corcoran
  • April 6, 2022
5 Tips for Dealing with Climate News
View Post
  • The Climate Optimist

Awareness Hurts & That’s OK, 5 Tips for Dealing with Climate News

  • Anne Therese Gennari
  • December 22, 2021
1 comment
  1. Pingback: Are You As Tired of the Cancel Culture Attitude As I Am? – MomOUTSPOKEN

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

KeiSei Weekly

Sign-Up for more Inspiration on Sustainable Living and Style Direct to Your Inbox

⁠ 55 3
Want to be in on a secret? ⁠ 40 2
Skincare or hair care? ⁠ 34 2
Have you been invited to a Halloween party and need some inspiration? ⁠ 23 1
Are you making the most of the cocooning season? ⁠ 35 2
Have you tried rental fashion yet?⁠ 40 3
KeiSei Magazine
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Terms of service
  • Privacy policy
© 2020 KeiSei Magazine Ltd.

Input your search keywords and press Enter.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Cookie settingsACCEPT
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT